Date:Friday July 13 2012
Back in January the FIA announced a tweak to how drivers could defend their position on the track.
It had been thought that the tweak would prevent drivers who make a move to defend their position away from the racing line, to return to it, thus blocking the attacking driver twice.
This scenario was seen multiple times during the course of the 2011 season and it was always going to be interesting to see how it would be enforced by the race stewards during the 2012 season and whether the advantage would now be handed to the attacking driver.
Well with the new season at its half way point, we've had a number of incidents which has meant that this rule has come under the spotlight.
In Bahrain Nico Rosberg, took a very aggressive approach towards defending his position against Lewis Hamilton, so much so that the Mercedes driver actually put two wheels off the track while the McLaren was alongside him.
The German was then under investigation for his defensive moves while attempting to keep the Ferrari of Fernando Alonso behind him later on in the same race.
The race stewards eventually sided with Rosberg, but calls were being made for clarification on the guidelines by the drivers, with Alonso making sarcastic tweets about the stewards decision.
In Valencia, Maldonado was punished for crashing into Lewis Hamilton in the closing stages of the race. The Williams driver attempted to blame the McLaren driver for pushing him off the track, but the stewards didn't agree and gave Maldonado a post-race time penalty.
While most agreed with the stewards decision, some Formula One journalists could see the point Maldonado was making in regards to the current regulations.
So before the British Grand Prix at Silverstone, FIA race director Charlie Whiting wrote to all the teams to clarify their position.
Autosport Magazine have managed to obtain a copy of this letter and have quoted parts of the letter in a recent article on their website.
'any driver defending his position on a straight and before any braking area may use the full width of the track during his first move provided no significant portion of the car attempting to pass is alongside his. Whilst defending in this way the driver may not leave the track without justifiable reason.'
It continued: 'For the avoidance of doubt, if any part of the front wing of the car attempting to pass is alongside the rear wheel of the car in front this will be deemed to be a 'significant portion'.'
Now this wouldn't appear to avoid doubt at all, just by looking at the incidents involving Rosberg and Hamilton in Bahrain and Hamilton and Maldonado in Valencia, you could still interpret the moves differently.
In Bahrain, Hamilton would have had a 'significant portion' of his car alongside Rosberg before the Mercedes used the full width of the road, so that would now lay blame on Rosberg.
In Valencia, despite the fact that Maldonado had put his car on the outside of the turn, he too would have had a 'significant portion' of his car alongside Hamilton, simply because he broke later than the McLaren. He then remained alongside him going into the chicane because he didn't attempt to take the initial turn and left the track.
So where does blame sit in this incident? Does it still sit with Maldonado for leaving the circuit and failing to rejoin the track in a safe manner or is Hamilton now to blame because the Brit didn't leave him enough of the track to take the corner?
Date:Friday July 13 2012
Renault target podium finish by 2018 (Friday February 5 2016)
Magnussen lands Renault drive (Thursday February 4 2016)
Maldonado leaves Renault & Formula One (Thursday February 4 2016)
Renault set for big unveil (Wednesday February 3 2016)
Championship not decided in Australia says Vettel (Tuesday February 2 2016)
Pirelli willing to change for Formula One (Monday February 1 2016)
Italian Grand Prix future set to be resolved (Friday January 29 2016)
Todt against F1 money divide (Thursday January 28 2016)
F1 Drivers call for 'Halo' introduction (Wednesday January 27 2016)
Have Honda found a break through? (Tuesday January 26 2016)
F1 scores own goal with Baku race? (Monday January 25 2016)
The evolution of Manor continues (Friday January 22 2016)
Sauber's 2016 car to miss first F1 test (Thursday January 21 2016)
F1 engine crisis averted (Wednesday January 20 2016)
2016 Formula One Calendar (Wednesday January 20 2016)
Channel 4 select 10 live F1 races (Tuesday January 19 2016)
F1 consider return of refuelling again (Monday January 18 2016)
Silverstone looks set to host F1 test (Friday January 15 2016)
Magnussen could replace Maldonado at Renault (Thursday January 14 2016)
Pirelli host wet tyre test at Paul Ricard circuit (Wednesday January 13 2016)
Coulthard joins Channel 4's F1 team (Tuesday January 12 2016)
Renault would welcome engine changes (Monday January 11 2016)
Grosjean is not using Haas as a stepping stone (Friday January 8 2016)
McLaren enjoying mature relationship with Honda (Thursday January 7 2016)
Haas target points in maiden Grand Prix (Wednesday January 6 2016)
2015 F1 Driver Standings (Tuesday January 5 2016)
2015 F1 Constructor Standings (Tuesday January 5 2016)
Praise for Verstappen and Sainz (Monday January 4 2016)
Rosberg's job is not in jeopardy says Hamilton (Friday January 1 2016)
Independent engine plan would be good for F1 (Thursday December 31 2015)
2016 will be a transitional year for Renault (Wednesday December 30 2015)
Stewards harsher on me says Maldonado (Tuesday December 29 2015)
Pirelli hand out their Christmas pressies! (Friday December 25 2015)
Battle of the heavyweights (Thursday December 24 2015)
Are Rosberg's days with Mercedes numbered? (Wednesday December 23 2015)
F1 will not return to Nurburgring (Tuesday December 22 2015)
Channel 4 to broadcast F1 from 2016 (Monday December 21 2015)
BBC dump Formula One (Monday December 21 2015)
Sauber under performed in 2015 (Friday December 18 2015)
Family influence to improve Kimi form (Thursday December 17 2015)
Ferrari hit back following Red Bull criticism (Wednesday December 16 2015)
F1 would have collapsed without Red Bull (Tuesday December 15 2015)
Hamilton & Rosberg are on the same page (Monday December 14 2015)
Hamilton receives F1 World Championship trophy (Friday December 11 2015)
Wolff reiterates strong stance with Merc drivers (Thursday December 10 2015)
Formula One could be destroyed says Bernie (Wednesday December 9 2015)
New tyre rules for Formula One in 2016 (Tuesday December 8 2015)
FIA approve Ferrari to supply fourth team (Monday December 7 2015)
TAG Heuer-branded engines to power Red Bull (Friday December 4 2015)
Renault confirm return (Friday December 4 2015)
Hamilton plays down Merc tensions (Friday December 4 2015)
FIA confirm 21 race calendar for 2016 (Friday December 4 2015)
Mercedes could dump Hamilton or Rosberg (Thursday December 3 2015)
Year ends with F1 tyre test (Wednesday December 2 2015)
Hamilton questions Mercedes tyre strategy (Tuesday December 1 2015)
Blog: Abu Dhabi GP Report (Monday November 30 2015)
2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - Race (Sunday November 29 2015)
Blog: Abu Dhabi Qualifying (Saturday November 28 2015)
2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - Qualifying (Saturday November 28 2015)
2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - FP3 (Saturday November 28 2015)
2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - FP2 (Friday November 27 2015)
2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - FP1 (Friday November 27 2015)
One final duel for 2015 (Thursday November 26 2015)
Blog: Abu Dhabi Preview (Thursday November 26 2015)
Former FIA boss slams Ferrari (Wednesday November 25 2015)
Renault takeover deal pretty much done (Tuesday November 24 2015)
2015 Formula One Prediction Competition - Round 19 (Monday November 23 2015)
Who will win in Abu Dhabi? (Monday November 23 2015)
Ferrari expect to beat Mercedes in 2016 (Friday November 20 2015)
Button belief in McLaren (Thursday November 19 2015)
Lowe defends Mercedes stance (Wednesday November 18 2015)
F1 has to change says Hamilton and Vettel (Tuesday November 17 2015)
Mercedes bashing after boring Brazil (Monday November 16 2015)
Blog: Brazilian GP Report (Monday November 16 2015)
2015 - Brazil GP - Race (Sunday November 15 2015)
Blog: Interlagos Qualifying (Saturday November 14 2015)
2015 - Brazil GP - Qualifying (Saturday November 14 2015)
2015 - Brazil GP - FP3 (Saturday November 14 2015)
2015 - Brazil GP - FP2 (Friday November 13 2015)
2015 - Brazil GP - FP1 (Friday November 13 2015)
Blog: Interlagos Preview (Friday November 13 2015)
Magnussen missed out on Haas drive (Thursday November 12 2015)
Pirelli set for 12 hour Abu Dhabi test (Wednesday November 11 2015)
Susie Wolff set to retire (Tuesday November 10 2015)
Blog:Why Hamiltonís pit questions were no big deal (Tuesday November 10 2015)
Formula One Prediction Competition - Round 18 (Monday November 9 2015)
Who will win in Brazil? (Monday November 9 2015)
Vettel holds hand up for poor Mexico showing (Friday November 6 2015)
Raikkonen points finger at Bottas (Thursday November 5 2015)
Mateschitz slams F1 engine suppliers (Wednesday November 4 2015)
Did Mercedes clip Hamilton's wings? (Wednesday November 4 2015)
Just days remaining to save Red Bull Racing? (Tuesday November 3 2015)
Blog: Mexican GP Report (Monday November 2 2015)
2015 - Mexico GP - Race (Sunday November 1 2015)
Blog: Mexico City Qualifying (Sunday November 1 2015)
2015 - Mexico GP - Qualifying (Saturday October 31 2015)
2015 - Mexico GP - FP3 (Saturday October 31 2015)
2015 - Mexico GP - FP2 (Friday October 30 2015)
2015 - Mexico GP - FP1 (Friday October 30 2015)
Best of the rest battle it out (Friday October 30 2015)
|7.||Push The Button||466|