Vital F1 | McNish V Hamilton
Vital Login
Social Login

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's F1, It's Vital'

McNish V Hamilton

When it comes to following F1 I've always supported my favourite driver, 99% based on them bring British but also a drivers style.

So it won't come as a surprise I'm a Hamilton fan.

When it comes to Touring Cars and Sports Cars I'm an Audi fan for various reasons, so throw McNish behind the wheel and he automatically becomes the driver I'm cheering on at Le Mans and various other places.

So I'm fairly unbiased in this, but once again McNish's decisions as race steward were pretty harsh towards Hamilton.

Even David Coulthard taking his devils advocate role usually believes Hamilton should be investigated by the stewards for getting out of bed, but on this occasion during the race he thought it was 'marginal' that this incident should be referred to the stewards.

Overall both Brundle and Coulthard thought there was no case to answer too during the race.

Some common sense in incidents like this would be nice, like Nigel Mansell showed at Silverstone, whilst McNish seems to be like an overzealous Premier League referee who applies the letter of the law from a rule book no matter the circumstances.

Yes technically trying to recover the car was dangerous, but so is staying side on in the middle of a slippery track. It's certainly not somewhere that I would like to have stayed still!

Paul di Resta was the only driver who had to take avoiding action, putting his back wheel on to the grass in the process. He himself said that he had plenty of time to react which would suggest it was safe...admittedly his manager is Lewis Hamilton's Dad so not a completely unbiased view, but I don't think it would be an outright lie!

So another harsh decision from McNish to add to the incidents at Monaco between Hamilton and Massa and Hamilton and Maldonado.

On those incidents Hamilton was the aggressor, so I can see why those decisions were made, although other drivers like Schumacher managed to race hard and fair and actually give room to the driver behind and avoid a collision, but why do these incidents even have to be reviewed. It's motor racing and racing incidents occur.

Other drivers make contact and do not get punished, Button colliding with Alonso in Canada is just one example, Alonso had to retire, Button went on to win the race!

It just would be nice to get some consistency (and perhaps not invite McNish back!)

Written by DJ

Want to be a guest writer on VitalF1.com?

It couldn't be simpler, just submit an article via this link and we'll publish your views.








Join Vital F1


It's easy to join up and join in on VitalF1.com, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

If you are already a member of Vital Football, your logins will automatically work on VitalF1.com!

The Journalist

Writer: DJ Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Tuesday August 2 2011

Time: 11:27AM

Your Comments

Nice article. I can't believe some of the decisions that go against Lewis. It's like he's racing under a whole different set of rules.
Rocky7
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Vital F1 Articles

Blog: Monaco Preview (Wednesday May 24 2017)

Who will win in Monaco? (Monday May 22 2017)

Blog: Spanish GP Report (Monday May 15 2017)

2017 Spain GP - Race (Sunday May 14 2017)

Blog: Barcelona Qualifying (Saturday May 13 2017)

2017 Spain GP - Qualifying (Saturday May 13 2017)

2017 Spain GP - FP3 (Saturday May 13 2017)

2017 Spain GP - FP2 (Friday May 12 2017)

2017 Spain GP - FP1 (Friday May 12 2017)

Blog: Barcelona Preview (Thursday May 11 2017)

Who will win in Spain? (Monday May 8 2017)

Track upgrades for Montreal (Wednesday May 3 2017)

Blog: Russian GP Report (Monday May 1 2017)

2017 Russia GP - Race (Sunday April 30 2017)

Blog: Sochi Qualifying (Saturday April 29 2017)

2017 Russia GP - Qualifying (Saturday April 29 2017)

2017 Russia GP - FP3 (Saturday April 29 2017)

2017 Russia GP - FP2 (Friday April 28 2017)

2017 Russia GP - FP1 (Friday April 28 2017)

Blog: Sochi Preview (Wednesday April 26 2017)

Who will win in Russia? (Monday April 24 2017)

Grid penalty for Sainz in Russia (Thursday April 20 2017)

Mercedes to implement team orders? (Wednesday April 19 2017)

Blog: Bahrain GP Report (Monday April 17 2017)

2017 Bahrain GP - Race (Sunday April 16 2017)

Blog: Sakhir Qualifying (Saturday April 15 2017)

2017 Bahrain GP - Qualifying (Saturday April 15 2017)

2017 Bahrain GP - FP3 (Saturday April 15 2017)

2017 Bahrain GP - FP2 (Friday April 14 2017)

2017 Bahrain GP - FP1 (Friday April 14 2017)

Blog: Sakhir Preview (Wednesday April 12 2017)

Who will win in Bahrain? (Tuesday April 11 2017)

Hamilton loving battle with Vettel (Tuesday April 11 2017)

Blog: Chinese GP Report (Monday April 10 2017)

2017 China GP - Race (Sunday April 9 2017)

Blog: Shanghai Qualifying (Saturday April 8 2017)

2017 China GP - Qualifying (Saturday April 8 2017)

2017 China GP - FP3 (Saturday April 8 2017)

2017 China GP - FP2 (Friday April 7 2017)

2017 China GP - FP1 (Friday April 7 2017)

Blog: Shanghai Preview (Wednesday April 5 2017)

Honda to supply Sauber? (Wednesday April 5 2017)

Who will win in China? (Monday April 3 2017)

Mixed feelings for Red Bull (Friday March 31 2017)

Blog: Australian GP Report (Monday March 27 2017)

2017 Australia GP - Race (Sunday March 26 2017)

2017 Australia GP - Qualifying (Saturday March 25 2017)

2017 Australia GP - FP3 (Saturday March 25 2017)

2017 Australia GP - FP2 (Saturday March 25 2017)

2017 Australia GP - FP1 (Saturday March 25 2017)

More calls to ban the shark fins (Friday March 24 2017)

Renault call for engine budget cap (Thursday March 23 2017)

Blog: Melbourne Preview (Thursday March 23 2017)

Renault can improve - Hopefully (Friday March 17 2017)

McLaren looking shaky (Wednesday March 15 2017)

Surtees dies aged 83 (Tuesday March 14 2017)

Ferrari end second test on top (Monday March 13 2017)

F1 ratings in UK collapse (Friday March 10 2017)

Brawn pushing for cash race for teams (Wednesday March 8 2017)

Archived Vital F1 Articles

List All Vital F1 Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. DJ 1138
2. Red5 1113
3. The Fear 773
4. Villaininthemerde 612
5. johnkelv 600
6. Druss_the_Legend 584
7. Push The Button 497
8. col8 334
9. The Intimidator 205
10. VanGisbergen2013 154

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Who will win in Monaco?
Hamilton 43%
Vettel 29%
Bottas 0%
Raikkonen 17%
Verstappen 11%
Ricciardo 0%
Someone else 0%