Vital F1 | McNish V Hamilton
Vital Login
Social Login

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's F1, It's Vital'

McNish V Hamilton

When it comes to following F1 I've always supported my favourite driver, 99% based on them bring British but also a drivers style.

So it won't come as a surprise I'm a Hamilton fan.

When it comes to Touring Cars and Sports Cars I'm an Audi fan for various reasons, so throw McNish behind the wheel and he automatically becomes the driver I'm cheering on at Le Mans and various other places.

So I'm fairly unbiased in this, but once again McNish's decisions as race steward were pretty harsh towards Hamilton.

Even David Coulthard taking his devils advocate role usually believes Hamilton should be investigated by the stewards for getting out of bed, but on this occasion during the race he thought it was 'marginal' that this incident should be referred to the stewards.

Overall both Brundle and Coulthard thought there was no case to answer too during the race.

Some common sense in incidents like this would be nice, like Nigel Mansell showed at Silverstone, whilst McNish seems to be like an overzealous Premier League referee who applies the letter of the law from a rule book no matter the circumstances.

Yes technically trying to recover the car was dangerous, but so is staying side on in the middle of a slippery track. It's certainly not somewhere that I would like to have stayed still!

Paul di Resta was the only driver who had to take avoiding action, putting his back wheel on to the grass in the process. He himself said that he had plenty of time to react which would suggest it was safe...admittedly his manager is Lewis Hamilton's Dad so not a completely unbiased view, but I don't think it would be an outright lie!

So another harsh decision from McNish to add to the incidents at Monaco between Hamilton and Massa and Hamilton and Maldonado.

On those incidents Hamilton was the aggressor, so I can see why those decisions were made, although other drivers like Schumacher managed to race hard and fair and actually give room to the driver behind and avoid a collision, but why do these incidents even have to be reviewed. It's motor racing and racing incidents occur.

Other drivers make contact and do not get punished, Button colliding with Alonso in Canada is just one example, Alonso had to retire, Button went on to win the race!

It just would be nice to get some consistency (and perhaps not invite McNish back!)

Written by DJ

Want to be a guest writer on

It couldn't be simpler, just submit an article via this link and we'll publish your views.

Join Vital F1

It's easy to join up and join in on, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

If you are already a member of Vital Football, your logins will automatically work on!

The Journalist

Writer: DJ Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Tuesday August 2 2011

Time: 11:27AM

Your Comments

Nice article. I can't believe some of the decisions that go against Lewis. It's like he's racing under a whole different set of rules.

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Vital F1 Articles

2016 Mexico GP - FP2 (Friday October 28 2016)

2016 Mexico GP - FP1 (Friday October 28 2016)

Blog: Mexico City Preview (Thursday October 27 2016)

Who will win in Mexico? (Thursday October 27 2016)

F1 introduces the Verstappen rule (Wednesday October 26 2016)

Red Bull family retains Kvyat (Tuesday October 25 2016)

Hamilton was in fear of engine issues (Monday October 24 2016)

Blog: US GP Report (Monday October 24 2016)

2016 United States GP - Race (Sunday October 23 2016)

Blog: Austin Qualifying (Sunday October 23 2016)

2016 United States GP - Qualifying (Saturday October 22 2016)

2016 United States GP - FP3 (Saturday October 22 2016)

2016 United States GP - FP2 (Friday October 21 2016)

2016 United States GP - FP1 (Friday October 21 2016)

Life will move on for Hamilton (Friday October 21 2016)

Blog: Austin Preview (Thursday October 20 2016)

Musical chairs continues in Austin (Wednesday October 19 2016)

Drivers make tyre selections for USA (Wednesday October 19 2016)

Who will win in the US of A? (Tuesday October 18 2016)

Hamilton having a mental meltdown? (Wednesday October 12 2016)

Has Rosberg wrapped up the 2016 title? (Tuesday October 11 2016)

Blog: Japanese GP Report (Sunday October 9 2016)

2016 Japanese GP - Race (Sunday October 9 2016)

Blog: Suzuka Qualifying (Saturday October 8 2016)

2016 Japanese GP - Qualifying (Saturday October 8 2016)

2016 Japanese GP - FP3 (Saturday October 8 2016)

2016 Japanese Grand Prix - FP2 (Friday October 7 2016)

2016 Japanese Grand Prix - FP1 (Friday October 7 2016)

Mercedes regroup following Malaysia (Thursday October 6 2016)

Blog: Suzuka Preview (Wednesday October 5 2016)

Who will win in Japan? (Tuesday October 4 2016)

Blog: Malaysian GP Report (Monday October 3 2016)

2016 Malaysia GP - Race (Sunday October 2 2016)

Blog: Sepang Qualifying (Saturday October 1 2016)

2016 Malaysia GP - Qualifying (Saturday October 1 2016)

Malaysia GP - FP3 (Saturday October 1 2016)

2016 Malaysia GP - FP2 (Friday September 30 2016)

2016 Malaysia GP - FP1 (Friday September 30 2016)

2016 the season of the swingers (Thursday September 29 2016)

Blog: Sepang Preview (Wednesday September 28 2016)

Ferrari fighting for best of the rest (Tuesday September 27 2016)

Horner hoping for another shot at Mercedes (Thursday September 22 2016)

F1 is boring says Alonso (Wednesday September 21 2016)

Singapore Swing? (Tuesday September 20 2016)

Who will win the Malaysian Grand Prix? (Monday September 19 2016)

Blog: Singapore GP Report (Sunday September 18 2016)

2016 Singapore GP - Race (Sunday September 18 2016)

Blog: Singapore Qualifying (Sunday September 18 2016)

2016 Singapore GP - Qualifying (Saturday September 17 2016)

2016 Singapore GP - FP3 (Saturday September 17 2016)

2016 Singapore GP - FP2 (Friday September 16 2016)

2016 Singapore GP - FP1 (Friday September 16 2016)

New upgrades for Haas and McLaren (Thursday September 15 2016)

Blog: Singapore Preview (Wednesday September 14 2016)

Drivers make tyre selections for Singapore (Tuesday September 13 2016)

Who will win in Singapore? (Monday September 12 2016)

Perez to stay with Force India (Friday September 9 2016)

Button to sit out 2017 Formula One season (Thursday September 8 2016)

Formula One sold (Thursday September 8 2016)

Is Kvyat about to lose his drive to Gasly? (Wednesday September 7 2016)

Massa announces retirement (Tuesday September 6 2016)

Blog: Italian GP Report (Tuesday September 6 2016)

Monza Saved (Monday September 5 2016)

Rosberg narrows championship deficit (Monday September 5 2016)

2016 Italian GP - Race (Sunday September 4 2016)

Blog: Monza Qualifying (Sunday September 4 2016)

2016 Italian GP - Qualifying (Saturday September 3 2016)

2016 Italian GP - FP3 (Saturday September 3 2016)

2016 Italian GP - FP2 (Friday September 2 2016)

2016 Italian GP - FP1 (Friday September 2 2016)

Blog: Monza Preview (Thursday September 1 2016)

Magnussen set for FIA fitness test (Wednesday August 31 2016)

Drivers make tyre selections for Italy (Wednesday August 31 2016)

Who will win in Italy? (Tuesday August 30 2016)

Blog: Belgian GP Report (Monday August 29 2016)

2016 Belgian Grand Prix - Race (Sunday August 28 2016)

Blog: Spa Qualifying (Saturday August 27 2016)

2016 Belgian Grand Prix - Qualifying (Saturday August 27 2016)

2016 Belgian Grand Prix - FP3 (Saturday August 27 2016)

2016 Belgian Grand Prix - FP2 (Friday August 26 2016)

2016 Belgian Grand Prix - FP1 (Friday August 26 2016)

Will Renault take up Magnussen option? (Thursday August 25 2016)

Hamilton set for huge grid penalty (Thursday August 25 2016)

Blog: Spa Preview (Wednesday August 24 2016)

Archived Vital F1 Articles

List All Vital F1 Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Red5 1104
2. DJ 1084
3. The Fear 773
4. Villaininthemerde 612
5. johnkelv 585
6. Druss_the_Legend 572
7. Push The Button 490
8. col8 334
9. The Intimidator 196
10. __villa__ 145

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Who will win the Mexico GP?
Rosberg 8%
Hamilton 72%
Ricciardo 5%
Verstappen 5%
Vettel 5%
Raikkonen 5%
Someone else 0%