Vital F1 - Alonso better than Schumacher?
Vital Login
Social Login

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's F1, It's Vital'

Alonso better than Schumacher?

With the Formula One summer break in full swing, some comments from Ferrari team principal Stefano Domenicali have got us thinking.

'For me, Fernando is the number one driver in F1 at the moment, I see a lot of similarities with Michael Schumacher, a driver who made his mark on our history. In fact, in some areas Fernando is even better, for example when I think of the speed with which he integrated himself into the team and the way he became its leader.

'In this he was much quicker than Michael who took a while to do that.'
Domenicali told Autosport Magazine.

Some high praise indeed, especially for a driver who is only in their second year with the team and has to-date has won just six races in Ferrari colours.

On hearing the news Alonso responded by saying: 'I don't know what to say, except that I immediately felt comfortable at Ferrari.

'But it would be very difficult to repeat what Michael did, because things are very different now to what they were a decade ago. Having said that, I am currently experiencing the best years of my career and that makes me very optimistic for the future.'


These comments got us at Vital F1 thinking, just who is better, Michael Schumacher or Fernando Alonso?

Obviously looking at the record books there is only one clear winner and that is the seven-time former Formula One World champion Michael Schumacher.

Between making his debut for Jordan in 2001 and his initial retirement at the end of the 2006 season, Schumacher won 91 races.

Alonso in just under ten full seasons in F1 has won 27 races.

But as Alonso alluded too in his comments, Formula One has changed dramatically in recent years and when Schumacher was at his unbeatable best, the Formula One landscape was unrecognisable to how it is today.

The past couple of seasons in Formula One have regularly seen three different teams winning races and having the most dominant car one weekend and apparently struggling at a different circuit a couple of weeks later.

But when Schumacher won five titles back-to-back between 2000 and 2004, F1 was not as open in comparison, with Ferrari dominating the competition.

For example in 2002 Ferrari won fifteen out of the seventeen races on the calender.

Schumacher for Williams and Coulthard for McLaren were the only drivers capable of breaking Ferrari's dominance with Schumacher winning eleven races.

In 2004 it was a similar story. Ferrari again won fifteen out of the eighteen races, with Schumacher claiming twelve wins in the opening thirteen races of the season, eventually ending the year with thirteen race wins.

But can you just discount Schumacher's record because his era was not as competitive as it is today? Or do you praise Schumacher and Ferrari for their dominance in a time when budgets were astronomical and in season testing was yet to be banned?

Or do you base your judgement on the drivers ability behind the wheel and give credit to Alonso for his style and race craft to get the best out of a car that isn't always as good as it's competitors?

It's an interesting topic and one that is impossible to judge simply because it's two very different era's of F1.

But with no action on the track it gave us something to think about.








Join Vital F1

It's easy to join up and join in on VitalF1.com, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

If you are already a member of Vital Football, your logins will automatically work on VitalF1.com!

The Journalist

Writer: Red5 Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday August 10 2011

Time: 12:00PM

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Vital F1 Articles

Wehrlein lands Manor driver (Wednesday February 10 2016)

Hamilton could have another decade in him (Wednesday February 10 2016)

Who will be Channel 4's lead presenter? (Tuesday February 9 2016)

Renault target podium finish by 2018 (Friday February 5 2016)

Magnussen lands Renault drive (Thursday February 4 2016)

Maldonado leaves Renault & Formula One (Thursday February 4 2016)

Renault set for big unveil (Wednesday February 3 2016)

Todt against F1 money divide (Thursday January 28 2016)

F1 Drivers call for 'Halo' introduction (Wednesday January 27 2016)

Have Honda found a break through? (Tuesday January 26 2016)

F1 scores own goal with Baku race? (Monday January 25 2016)

The evolution of Manor continues (Friday January 22 2016)

Sauber's 2016 car to miss first F1 test (Thursday January 21 2016)

F1 engine crisis averted (Wednesday January 20 2016)

2016 Formula One Calendar (Wednesday January 20 2016)

Channel 4 select 10 live F1 races (Tuesday January 19 2016)

Silverstone looks set to host F1 test (Friday January 15 2016)

Coulthard joins Channel 4's F1 team (Tuesday January 12 2016)

Renault would welcome engine changes (Monday January 11 2016)

Haas target points in maiden Grand Prix (Wednesday January 6 2016)

2015 F1 Driver Standings (Tuesday January 5 2016)

2015 F1 Constructor Standings (Tuesday January 5 2016)

Praise for Verstappen and Sainz (Monday January 4 2016)

Stewards harsher on me says Maldonado (Tuesday December 29 2015)

Battle of the heavyweights (Thursday December 24 2015)

Are Rosberg's days with Mercedes numbered? (Wednesday December 23 2015)

F1 will not return to Nurburgring (Tuesday December 22 2015)

Channel 4 to broadcast F1 from 2016 (Monday December 21 2015)

BBC dump Formula One (Monday December 21 2015)

Sauber under performed in 2015 (Friday December 18 2015)

Family influence to improve Kimi form (Thursday December 17 2015)

F1 would have collapsed without Red Bull (Tuesday December 15 2015)

Hamilton & Rosberg are on the same page (Monday December 14 2015)

Formula One could be destroyed says Bernie (Wednesday December 9 2015)

New tyre rules for Formula One in 2016 (Tuesday December 8 2015)

Renault confirm return (Friday December 4 2015)

Hamilton plays down Merc tensions (Friday December 4 2015)

FIA confirm 21 race calendar for 2016 (Friday December 4 2015)

Mercedes could dump Hamilton or Rosberg (Thursday December 3 2015)

Year ends with F1 tyre test (Wednesday December 2 2015)

Blog: Abu Dhabi GP Report (Monday November 30 2015)

2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - Race (Sunday November 29 2015)

Blog: Abu Dhabi Qualifying (Saturday November 28 2015)

2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - Qualifying (Saturday November 28 2015)

2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - FP3 (Saturday November 28 2015)

2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - FP2 (Friday November 27 2015)

2015 - Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - FP1 (Friday November 27 2015)

One final duel for 2015 (Thursday November 26 2015)

Blog: Abu Dhabi Preview (Thursday November 26 2015)

Former FIA boss slams Ferrari (Wednesday November 25 2015)

Renault takeover deal pretty much done (Tuesday November 24 2015)

Who will win in Abu Dhabi? (Monday November 23 2015)

Ferrari expect to beat Mercedes in 2016 (Friday November 20 2015)

Button belief in McLaren (Thursday November 19 2015)

Lowe defends Mercedes stance (Wednesday November 18 2015)

Mercedes bashing after boring Brazil (Monday November 16 2015)

Blog: Brazilian GP Report (Monday November 16 2015)

2015 - Brazil GP - Race (Sunday November 15 2015)

Blog: Interlagos Qualifying (Saturday November 14 2015)

2015 - Brazil GP - Qualifying (Saturday November 14 2015)

2015 - Brazil GP - FP3 (Saturday November 14 2015)

2015 - Brazil GP - FP2 (Friday November 13 2015)

2015 - Brazil GP - FP1 (Friday November 13 2015)

Blog: Interlagos Preview (Friday November 13 2015)

Magnussen missed out on Haas drive (Thursday November 12 2015)

Pirelli set for 12 hour Abu Dhabi test (Wednesday November 11 2015)

Susie Wolff set to retire (Tuesday November 10 2015)

Who will win in Brazil? (Monday November 9 2015)

Raikkonen points finger at Bottas (Thursday November 5 2015)

Mateschitz slams F1 engine suppliers (Wednesday November 4 2015)

Did Mercedes clip Hamilton's wings? (Wednesday November 4 2015)

Blog: Mexican GP Report (Monday November 2 2015)

2015 - Mexico GP - Race (Sunday November 1 2015)

Blog: Mexico City Qualifying (Sunday November 1 2015)

Archived Vital F1 Articles

List All Vital F1 Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Red5 1072
2. DJ 997
3. The Fear 773
4. Villaininthemerde 612
5. johnkelv 583
6. Druss_the_Legend 551
7. Push The Button 466
8. col8 334
9. The Intimidator 176
10. __villa__ 145

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Have Mercedes handled the final races well?
They have achieved one-two finishes so yes! 17%
No, they have engineered the results with no racin 83%