Date:Thursday April 12 2012
The Mercedes rear wing row has dragged on into a third Grand Prix and Lotus, as previously expected, have now filed an official protest with the FIA.
Speaking before the protest was made, Mercedes boss Ross Brawn remained confused about why the situation was still ongoing.
'I think it is disappointing after three races that we are still in this situation, The system hasn't changed and the FIA's position hasn't changed, and as far as I understand their arguments haven't changed. So if they protest now, why didn't they protest in Australia? There is nothing new.'
It's a very good question and why now?
The Mercedes system has been well documented for around a month now and it would seem to be quite clear how it works.
The concept is, in a way, similar to the F-duct-type device which had previously been developed by McLaren and others in previous seasons.
That concept has been banned as any device which is seen as driver operated is now deemed as illegal by the FIA.
Mercedes version appears to be a hole on the rear wing endplate. The purpose of it appears to be to direct air to the front wing of the car, to basically give it a straightline speed boost.
In Australia the Mercedes was regularly around 8kph quicker than Red Bull in the speedtraps, giving them good performances in qualifying and were also strong through the two DRS Zone's in the race.
It works when the driver activates the DRS, the rear wing moves, which then uncovers the hole and immediately it begins to directed air to the front wing to 'stall it' for a speed boost.
As it appears to be only active when the driver enables the DRS their argument is that it is illegal.
FIA race director Charlie Whiting didn't agree, he of course has had a detailed look at the Mercedes design and knows and understands exactly how it works, something the other teams do not have the benefit of.
It might be against the spirit of the rules as McLaren have said, but it doesn't appear to directly break the regulations and Mercedes believe the concept has been in place for two years.
'It is a matter of record that in 2010 Charlie [Whiting] stated that such a system was legal. It is in the minutes of the [technical] working group meetings. The question was asked and he stated his opinion then that he considered it legal. It has not been going on for three races. It has been going on for two years.' Brawn added.
Which again begs the question, why protest now?
The Lotus protest comes under article 3.15 of the technical regulations. If you do not have your book to hand, the important quote is as follows: 'With the exception of the parts necessary for the adjustment described in Article 3.18, any car system, device or procedure which uses driver movement as a means of altering the aerodynamic characteristics of the car is prohibited,'
So basically because the device becomes active when a driver activates the DRS, they believe the device is driver enabled, which was their complaint over a month ago, so again why now?
The protest even includes a €2,000 deposit, small change for a Formula One team, but a measure of their intent?
The Mercedes system is difficult to copy, Ross Brawn has already admitted this, which also means that if Mercedes are forced to take it off their car, a big part of their design concept is taken away from them.
'If the protest is upheld and Mercedes have to change the design of their car then that is effectively their season written off, It would be a big hit and they will be fighting tooth and nail to get this protest turned down.' Sky Sports Ted Kravitz told their news channel.
The fact that making the device illegal will hurt Mercedes more than if Lotus simply copied it, is probably one of the major reasons behind the protest.
Date:Thursday April 12 2012
Vital talking point: Hungary - Merc stalling? (Tuesday July 28 2015)
Blog: Hungarian GP Report (Monday July 27 2015)
2015 Hungary GP - Race (Sunday July 26 2015)
Blog: Hungaroring Qualifying (Saturday July 25 2015)
2015 Hungary GP - Qualifying (Saturday July 25 2015)
2015 Hungary GP - FP3 (Saturday July 25 2015)
2015 - Hungary GP - FP2 (Friday July 24 2015)
2015 - Hungary GP - FP1 (Friday July 24 2015)
They will continue to race hard for Bianchi (Thursday July 23 2015)
Drivers mourn at Bianchi's funeral (Wednesday July 22 2015)
Blog: Hungaroring Preview (Tuesday July 21 2015)
Formula One Prediction Competition - Round 10 (Tuesday July 21 2015)
Who will win in Hungary? (Tuesday July 21 2015)
Sad day for the sport and the team says Lowdon (Monday July 20 2015)
Chilton dedicates win to Bianchi (Monday July 20 2015)
Jules Bianchi dies aged 25 (Saturday July 18 2015)
Will Germans back Hockenheim race? (Friday July 17 2015)
McLaren trying to unlock potential (Thursday July 16 2015)
Red Bull lack patience (Wednesday July 15 2015)
Bianchi's father 'less optimistic' over recovery (Tuesday July 14 2015)
Blog: What has happened to the Strategy Group? (Monday July 13 2015)
Button's future up in the air (Friday July 10 2015)
Hamilton wants more control (Thursday July 9 2015)
Mercedes to power Red Bull Racing? (Wednesday July 8 2015)
Vital talking point - Did Williams get it wrong? (Tuesday July 7 2015)
Blog: British GP Report (Tuesday July 7 2015)
Records fall for Hamilton (Monday July 6 2015)
Vital talking point: Hamilton's pit, was it luck? (Monday July 6 2015)
2015 - British GP - Race result (Sunday July 5 2015)
Blog: Silverstone Qualifying (Sunday July 5 2015)
2015 - British GP - Qualifying (Saturday July 4 2015)
2015 - British GP - FP3 (Saturday July 4 2015)
2015 - British GP - FP2 (Friday July 3 2015)
2015 - British GP - FP1 (Friday July 3 2015)
Yet more gimmicks from F1 Strategy Group (Friday July 3 2015)
Hamilton calls for better trophies (Thursday July 2 2015)
Blog: Silverstone Preview (Wednesday July 1 2015)
Formula E cannot compare with F1 says Horner (Wednesday July 1 2015)
Pirelli to request more F1 tests (Tuesday June 30 2015)
2015 Formula One Prediction Competition - Round 9 (Tuesday June 30 2015)
Who will win the British Grand Prix? (Tuesday June 30 2015)
New contract for Horner (Monday June 29 2015)
F1 teams are all talk says Todt (Monday June 29 2015)
Formula 1 v Formula E (Monday June 29 2015)
Positive test for McLaren (Friday June 26 2015)
Mosley praise for Ecclestone (Thursday June 25 2015)
Mercedes remain on top in second test (Thursday June 25 2015)
Miami Dolphins owner to buy a stake in F1 (Wednesday June 24 2015)
Red Bull to sack Horner? (Wednesday June 24 2015)
Rain hampers running on first test day (Wednesday June 24 2015)
Ferrari to hand Red Bull a lifeline? (Tuesday June 23 2015)
Angry Mateschitz (Tuesday June 23 2015)
Vital talking point: Austria - ah, erm, err (Monday June 22 2015)
Blog: Austrian GP Report (Sunday June 21 2015)
2015 Austrian GP - Race (Sunday June 21 2015)
Blog: Red Bull Ring Qualifying (Saturday June 20 2015)
Four drivers hit with penalties (Saturday June 20 2015)
2015 Austrian GP - Qualifying (Saturday June 20 2015)
2015 Austrian GP - FP3 (Saturday June 20 2015)
2015 Austrian GP - FP2 (Friday June 19 2015)
2015 Austrian GP - FP1 (Friday June 19 2015)
Italian Grand Prix to alternate? (Thursday June 18 2015)
Will Michelin return to Formula One? (Thursday June 18 2015)
Blog: Red Bull Ring Preview (Wednesday June 17 2015)
2015 Formula One Prediction Competition - Round 8 (Tuesday June 16 2015)
Who will win in Austria? (Tuesday June 16 2015)
Hulkenberg wins Le Mans (Monday June 15 2015)
Head knighted (Monday June 15 2015)
Boullier calls for engine regulation change (Friday June 12 2015)
F1 holds new talks over New Jersey race (Thursday June 11 2015)
F1 regulations too complex for Ferrari chairman (Wednesday June 10 2015)
Grosjean apology for Stevens (Wednesday June 10 2015)
Rosberg & Vettel not good for F1 says Bernie (Wednesday June 10 2015)
Renault quit threat very real (Tuesday June 9 2015)
Blog: Canadian GP Report (Tuesday June 9 2015)
Vital talking point: Can it get worse for McLaren? (Monday June 8 2015)
2015 - Canada - Race (Sunday June 7 2015)
Blog: Montreal Qualifying (Sunday June 7 2015)
Grid penalty brings further pain for Vettel (Sunday June 7 2015)
2015 - Canada - Qualifying (Sunday June 7 2015)
2015 - Canada - FP3 (Sunday June 7 2015)
Why customer cars are not against F1’s DNA (Saturday June 6 2015)
2015 - Canada - FP2 (Friday June 5 2015)
2015 - Canada - FP1 (Friday June 5 2015)
Verstappen under fire (Friday June 5 2015)
Manor Marussia sign Fabio Leimer (Thursday June 4 2015)
Blog: Montreal Preview (Wednesday June 3 2015)
Manor Marussia make key appointments (Wednesday June 3 2015)
Ferrari and Honda set for engine upgrades (Tuesday June 2 2015)
2015 Formula One Prediction Competition - Round 7 (Monday June 1 2015)
Who will in Canada? (Monday June 1 2015)
F1 seeks new team for 2016 and beyond (Friday May 29 2015)
Extra homework for Kimi (Friday May 29 2015)
Verstappen penalised for Monaco crash (Thursday May 28 2015)
HSE to take no action over de Villota crash (Wednesday May 27 2015)
Vital talking point - First points for McLaren (Wednesday May 27 2015)
Mature Hamilton attempts to deflect blame (Tuesday May 26 2015)
Wolff attempts to defend the indefensible (Tuesday May 26 2015)
Vital talking point - Monaco - Mercedes Blunder (Tuesday May 26 2015)
Blog: Monaco GP Report (Monday May 25 2015)
|7.||Push The Button||461|