Vital F1 | Drivers ask for clarity on overtaking rules
Vital Login
Social Login

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's F1, It's Vital'

Drivers ask for clarity on overtaking rules

One of the biggest talking points after the Bahrain Grand Prix, especially on the VitalF1.com forum was the incidents involving Mercedes Nico Rosberg, McLaren's Lewis Hamilton and Ferrari's Fernando Alonso.

The two incidents, both involving the Mercedes driver, were both investigated after the race, but the race stewards decided that no punishments were required.

Nico Rosberg was investigated for defending his position in a dangerous fashion, but the race stewards decided that he made just one continuous move before either Hamilton or Alonso were alongside him and judged it legal.

Others argued that he forced both Lewis Hamilton and Fernando Alonso off the track, which of course is dangerous and is illegal, after new regulation were brought in for 2012 to prevent such moves which were similar to Michael Schumacher's defending techniques at the Italian Grand Prix in 2011.

'I judged it to be harsh but fair, according to the rules we have and I didn't judge that it was putting my compadres in danger.' Rosberg told the BBC.

But while Rosberg obviously felt he was in the right and feels vindicated by the race stewards decision, the German driver does want the issues raised in the drivers meeting in Spain this weekend, as both Hamilton and Alonso have raised concerns.

He continued: 'we need to discuss it because they felt in danger which I didn't intentionally do, of course not,'

McLaren driver Lewis Hamilton wasn't so much critical of the move or the decision, but called for the rules to be clarified: 'Fortunately neither of us got in trouble or hurt.

'Hopefully we will try to make the rules a little bit clearer so we won't be in that position again.'


Ferrari driver Fernando Alonso made a sarcastic comment on his Twitter account after the decision, tweeting: 'I think you are going to have fun in future races! You can defend position as you want and you can overtake outside the track! Enjoy!'

The point Alonso makes is a valid one, if Rosberg is adjudged to be in the right then why wasn't Lewis Hamilton punished for overtaking off the track?

That point was argued on VitalF1 via this blog feature from the F1podcast guys and has also been raised by other drivers.

Red Bull's Mark Webber said: 'I was surprised Lewis was allowed to keep his position.

'It was for sure a situation Lewis didn't want to put himself in either, finding himself completely off the track, but ultimately the move was allowed to be kept.

'I'm sure we'll talk a bit more about it in the drivers' briefing.'


While Hamilton's McLaren team-mate also asked the same question: 'The problem with that manoeuvre is if Nico doesn't get penalised for pushing off the track, that means Lewis overtook off track,

'One of them should have been penalised whereas they both got away with it. It's difficult to know where the line is then.'


The VitalF1 poll showed that most of the VitalF1 users felt that Rosberg was more to blame in the incidents.

48% believed Rosberg should have been penalised for both moves with Hamilton and Alonso.

11% felt he should have just been penalised for the move on Alonso, 2% just for the move on Hamilton, while 39% believed the decision to not penalise him was correct.








Join Vital F1

It's easy to join up and join in on VitalF1.com, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

If you are already a member of Vital Football, your logins will automatically work on VitalF1.com!

The Journalist

Writer: Red5 Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Friday May 11 2012

Time: 12:00PM

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Vital F1 Articles

Is Formula E a threat to Formula One? (Wednesday August 16 2017)

F1 to introduce standardised parts? (Monday August 14 2017)

Sainz fake news (Saturday August 12 2017)

Hungaroring set for revamp (Wednesday August 9 2017)

Drivers mixed on Halo introduction (Monday August 7 2017)

Sauber ditch Honda for Ferrari (Thursday August 3 2017)

Blog: Hungarian GP Report (Wednesday August 2 2017)

2017 Hungarian GP - Race (Sunday July 30 2017)

2017 Hungarian GP - Qualifying (Saturday July 29 2017)

2017 Hungarian GP - FP3 (Saturday July 29 2017)

2017 Hungarian GP - FP2 (Friday July 28 2017)

2017 Hungarian GP - FP1 (Friday July 28 2017)

Halo will debut in F1 in 2018 (Friday July 28 2017)

Blog: Hungaroring Preview (Thursday July 27 2017)

Cosworth to return to Formula One? (Wednesday July 26 2017)

Who will win in Hungary (Monday July 24 2017)

Sympathy for Kvyat? (Thursday July 20 2017)

Vettel plays down Silverstone swing (Wednesday July 19 2017)

Hamiltonís takeover (Tuesday July 18 2017)

Blog: British GP Report (Monday July 17 2017)

2017 British GP - Race (Sunday July 16 2017)

Blog: Silverstone Qualifying (Sunday July 16 2017)

2017 British GP - Qualifying (Sunday July 16 2017)

2017 British GP - FP3 (Sunday July 16 2017)

2017 British GP - FP2 (Friday July 14 2017)

2017 British GP - FP1 (Friday July 14 2017)

Who will win the British Grand Prix? (Thursday July 13 2017)

Blog: Silverstone Preview (Wednesday July 12 2017)

Blog: Austrian GP Report (Monday July 10 2017)

2017 Austria GP - Race (Sunday July 9 2017)

Blog: Red Bull Ring Qualifying (Saturday July 8 2017)

2017 Austria GP - Qualifying (Saturday July 8 2017)

2017 Austria GP - FP3 (Saturday July 8 2017)

2017 Austria GP - FP2 (Friday July 7 2017)

2017 Austrian GP - FP1 (Friday July 7 2017)

Blog: Red Bull Ring Preview (Thursday July 6 2017)

Hulkenberg sets sights on 2018 (Wednesday July 5 2017)

Who will win in Austria? (Monday July 3 2017)

The Force is not with India (Thursday June 29 2017)

Lauda and Wolff on Vettel (Wednesday June 28 2017)

Hamilton and Ricciardo slam Vettel (Tuesday June 27 2017)

Blog: Azerbaijan GP Report (Monday June 26 2017)

2017 Azerbaijan GP - Race (Sunday June 25 2017)

Blog: Baku Qualifying (Saturday June 24 2017)

2017 Azerbaijan GP - Qualifying (Saturday June 24 2017)

2017 Azerbaijan GP - FP3 (Saturday June 24 2017)

2017 Azerbaijan GP - FP2 (Friday June 23 2017)

2017 Azerbaijan GP - FP1 (Friday June 23 2017)

Blog: Baku Preview (Thursday June 22 2017)

F1 too boring for Malaysia (Wednesday June 21 2017)

Who will win in Baku? (Monday June 19 2017)

Kvyat rant at 'circus' stewarding (Thursday June 15 2017)

Merc hit Ferrari with heavy blow (Tuesday June 13 2017)

Blog: Canadian GP Report (Monday June 12 2017)

2017 Canada GP - Race (Sunday June 11 2017)

Blog: Montreal Qualifying (Sunday June 11 2017)

2017 Canada GP - Qualifying (Saturday June 10 2017)

2017 Canada GP - FP3 (Saturday June 10 2017)

2017 Canada GP - FP2 (Friday June 9 2017)

2017 Canada GP - FP1 (Friday June 9 2017)

Formula One season set to expand (Thursday June 8 2017)

Blog: Montreal Preview (Tuesday June 6 2017)

Who will win in Canada? (Monday June 5 2017)

Youngster set to return to F1 (Friday June 2 2017)

Mercedes war with Ferrari not over (Wednesday May 31 2017)

All talk on Ferrari (Tuesday May 30 2017)

Blog: Monaco GP Report (Monday May 29 2017)

2017 Monaco GP - Race (Sunday May 28 2017)

Blog: Monaco Qualifying (Saturday May 27 2017)

2017 Monaco GP - Qualifying (Saturday May 27 2017)

2017 Monaco GP - FP3 (Saturday May 27 2017)

2017 Monaco GP - FP2 (Thursday May 25 2017)

2017 Monaco GP - FP1 (Thursday May 25 2017)

Blog: Monaco Preview (Wednesday May 24 2017)

Who will win in Monaco? (Monday May 22 2017)

Archived Vital F1 Articles

List All Vital F1 Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. DJ 1160
2. Red5 1120
3. The Fear 773
4. Villaininthemerde 612
5. johnkelv 601
6. Druss_the_Legend 590
7. Push The Button 503
8. col8 334
9. The Intimidator 211
10. VanGisbergen2013 168

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Was Hamilton right to move over for Bottas?
No 9%
Yes - It was a team order 33%
Yes - But naive team order 58%